Fact is none of us know any of these people. And none of us know what happened with Elaine and John's marriage. So we don't know if John or Elaine cheated on eachother or if they left the marriage for someone else, or if they just grew apart which happens a lot. It's just guessing. And it's sad to see gossipwebsites taking advantage of it by making up stories.
EDITED. From
Radaronline:
Musician John Mellencamp has filed for divorce from his wife, Elaine, after nearly 18 years of marriage claiming the union is irretrievably broken, and RadarOnline.com has exclusive new details behind the star's split.
According to court documents filed January 14 in Brown County, Indiana, John and Elaine married on September 5, 1992 and
physically separated on or about September 1, 2010.The couple has two children, age 16 and 15, and Elaine is not currently pregnant.
John, who is in possession of the couple's Prenuptial Agreement, states in court documents that the Prenup is valid and binding and will govern the distribution of the marital property.
In addition, John also requests that Elaine be restored to her maiden name of "Irwin."The documents note that the couple intends to submit a Confidential Child and Property Settlement Agreement to the court for review and approval, requesting an entry of Summary Degree with no future hearings.
John and Elaine met in 1991 when she modeled for the cover of his album, Whenever We Wanted.